Does Exodus: Gods and Kings deserve to be banned for historical inaccuracy? The 3D Exodus: Gods and Kings, starring Christian Bale as Moses rising up against the Pharaoh Ramses, earned $24.1m in its debut weekend in the US, according to box office tracker Exhibitor Relations. ^ Phillipa Hawker (December 5, 2014). Retrieved December 7, 2014. Exodus: Gods and Kings received generally negative reviews from critics. Exodus: Gods and Kings is a new action adventure drama from Ridley Scott based on the book of Exodus and retold from the perspective of a sibling rivalry.Instead of casting Russell Crowe for the third time, after Robin Hood and his former glory, Gladiator, Scott has enticed Christian Bale to play his hero, Moses. Nobody is enjoying themselves. “I’m just not going to get it financed.” This may have been an accurate reflection of the prejudices of some financiers, but it did nothing to quell public criticism. I made the following changes: After Kadesh, Moses returns to Egypt, where Jewish slaves are working away on some monuments, colossal statues and a pyramid. "Don't be afraid..." Gravitas Ventures has released an official trailer for Exodus, a peculiar new old school sci-fi adventure of sorts. The plagues are strikingly recreated from a visual effects point of view, but one of Rameses’ cronies pops up to provide boring rational explanations for them; and the Red Sea just sort of goes away of its own accord. There is an avalanche, and he is hit several times on the head by big rocks. Yet TV and film have long been happy to whitewash not just history, but also fiction – see the endless debates about whether fictional characters can be played by a person of colour (eg James Bond) and the lack of shame around casting white actors as brown people (see Ridley Scott’s Exodus: Gods and Kings). Your support powers our independent journalism, Available for everyone, funded by readers, The actor spoke about the optimistic message of his new sci-fi adventure alongside at the Toronto film festival, In this week’s instalment of our series tracking cinema’s worldwide winners …, Accusations of racism over the casting of this blockbuster are the least of its many epic problems, writes, A day after Morocco bans film, Egypt says it’s rife with mistakes, including an apparent claim that ‘Moses and the Jews built the pyramids’, Final Hobbit movie takes $90.6m, contributing to $355.6m global haul so far, while Exodus suffers and Night at the Museum 3 disappoints, Two planned films about the life of Christ are unlikely to be welcomed by traditional believers, but reflect a renewed interest in Bible epics, As Ridley Scott prepares to release another blockbuster based on the exodus, the row has reignited the debate over whether Judaism’s historical saviour actually existed. When a VHS-tape proves the existence of a rumored doorway to paradise, a young man abandons his decaying hometown in … The topic of Moses is current since Exodus: Gods and Kings comes out … Exodus: Gods and Kings review – holy Moses, wholly acceptable for the devout, cinemas in Morocco have also been forbidden, drawn the governments of the United States and North Korea into a diplomatic contretemps, the idea that the pyramids were built by slave labour. Palestinian Christians find no cry for freedom in the Exodus story, Exodus: Gods and Kings review – biblical epic drowned by its dramatic failings, Egypt bans 'Zionist' film Exodus and cites 'historical inaccuracies', The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies triumphs at US box office, A zealot, a rebel, but no miracle-worker: film studios plot a secular take on life of Jesus, Unbroken, Night at the Museum 3, Exodus and Annie: film reviews – video, Germany can't kick the Hobbit: Bilbophilia sweeps Europe, Exodus hits No 1 in US despite weak prophet, while Top Five lands at No 4, Joel Edgerton: 'I gotta step up to the plate with Christian Bale and prove my mettle', Christian Bale defends Ridley Scott over Exodus ‘whitewashing’. This has been a fraught issue in Egypt at least since Israeli prime minister Menachem Begin claimed in 1977 that Israel’s forefathers built the pyramids. So Exodus: Gods and Kings is outrageous hokum on many levels -- including, as it seems to this lay observer, the religious ones. Photograph: Rex Features. ScreenPlay. Joel Edgerton talks to Red Carpet News at the London premiere of biblical epic Exodus Gods and Kings. Basketball Forever. It also mixes him up with the Cambridge spy ring in a way that seriously impugns his historical reputation – and is completely untrue. Perhaps the film-makers are even hoping that controversy might help it make a decent return on its $140m budget. Category: Exodus: Gods and Kings Exodus: Gods and Kings (Movie Review 2014) 3 Kernels. The film's Moses (a gym-toned Christian Bale) is a … An article appeared in the Guardian last week asking if Moses was just a myth.. 2. As I write this review, I do hope God doesn’t think I’m reviewing him. Exodus: Gods and Kings - Trailer for Exodus: Gods and Kings. Historians may raise their eyebrows but, as far as most film-makers are concerned, these are the good bits. 3:08. Exodus: Gods and Kings (April 11/16) Ridley Scott's worst movie since Kingdom of Heaven , Exodus: Gods and Kings follows Christian Bale's Moses as he embarks on a perilous quest to lead Egypt's slaves to safe haven - much to the chagrin of the country's petulant leader, Ramses (Joel Edgerton). The Sydney Morning Herald. The film stages a foray into the historical record with a visually impressive recreation of the battle of Kadesh, circa 1274 BC, fought by the Egyptians against the Hittites in what is now Syria. After realising that he himself is a Jew by birth, Moses climbs a holy mountain. 'Exodus: Gods and Kings review – holy Moses, wholly acceptable for the devout'. It only adds to the movie’s clunky, 1950s feel: it has all the puffed-up high camp of a Charlton Heston swords-and-sandals epic, without any of the fun. 'Exodus: Gods and Kings review: Ridley Scott's biblical epic is equally inspired and plagued'. Might it turn out as non-kosher as Noah, 2014’s other Old Testament epic? 20th Century Fox Two powerful men – brothers from other mothers and great friends since childhood – find their relationship tested when the father of one (but guardian to both) makes it … Ridley Scott’s Exodus: Gods and Kings is a gloriously epic depiction of Moses and the story of his taking on the Egyptian Pharaoh … 38 Slant Magazine Eric Henderson But the money is good, $10,000 a week, and Zoe's step-mother (Indira Varma, Exodus: Gods and Kings) demands a female bodyguard because Zoe has a propensity for sleeping with her male ones. Onscreen, Moses wages a guerrilla war against the Egyptians. It is one of the main things that has irritated the Egyptian culture minister now, and he has a point. Please take a moment to review my edit. Is the film historically inaccurate, though, as the Egyptian culture minister charges? Guilty of misrepresentation: The Imitation Game. The real Rameses II commanded the Egyptian forces. (In The Ten Commandments, though, Cecil B DeMille only managed four plagues: he couldn’t work out how to do frogs, flies, lice, boils, locusts or the death of livestock with the special-effects technology of the 1950s.). In the first place, most historians would not treat the Book of Exodus as an entirely literal or reliable source. Retrieved December 8, 2014. The story of Moses may have some truth at its core, but it is buried in layers of bronze age vagueness and myth. Ridley Scott brought all his filmmaker skills to Exodus: Gods and Kings and the movie is a visually sumptuous. The Middle East provides a nice visual backdrop to this story and the movie deserves to be seen on the large screen. Mixed 'Exodus: Gods and Kings' Reviews Have Landed ... See a range of reviews below. Exodus: Gods and Kings tells the story of Moses leading his people to freedom. VICE. Black Hawk Down, Exodus director Ridley Scott’s 2001 dramatisation of the battle of Mogadishu, was taken to task by the president of Pakistan Pervez Musharraf for its perceived slights against his nation’s troops. Crowe played a cruel mix of Noah for Darren … Meanwhile, Exodus: Gods and Kings has been annoying people since before its release, notably when it announced an almost entirely white cast to play its Middle Eastern and African characters. It took the No 1 spot at the US box office, but with $24.5m in first-week takings scored significantly lower than comparable biblical epics The Passion of the Christ ($83.8m) and Noah ($43.7m). However, after you see this movie, that’s just about what you may end up doing. Kadesh is sometimes said to have been the largest chariot battle ever fought, with thousands of chariots on both sides. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information. Exodus: Gods and Kings opens in US cinemas on 12 December and arrives in the UK on Boxing day. As he blows up warehouses and ships in spectacular yet ahistorical fashion, viewers may wonder: is this film trying to suggest Moses was a terrorist? But is it more guilty of being pompous and badly scripted? This was a strange twist to the storyline, although essential for Scott’s presentation. He’s not alone. In the final cut, the white actors look ludicrous under caked-on bronzer, their inauthentically blue eyes emphasised by heavy Egyptian kohl. © 2021 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. Meanwhile, Exodus: Gods and Kings never quite figures out how it’s going to deal with the magic stuff, and fudges it. Like earlier Hollywood Moses movies The Ten Commandments (1956) and Prince of Egypt (1998), Exodus: Gods and Kings identifies Rameses II as the pharaoh. Feb. 2, 2021 - Tenacious ‘Tenet’ Still Soaring on VOD Charts as ‘News of the World’ Stays Strong IndieWire - www.indiewire.comTenacious ‘Tenet’ Still Soaring on VOD Charts as ‘News of the World’ Stays Strong - IndieWire; Feb. 3, 2021 - The top 10 movies on the iTunes Store Richmond News - www.richmond-news.comThe top 10 movies … One problem for those who try to ban movies is that this may only increase their appeal. MonProgrammeTV. I had high expectations for Exodus: Gods And Kings based on the fact it was directed by Ridley Scott who did one of my favorite movies of all time - Alien.The fact that Sigourney Weaver, who starred in Alien, also appears in Exodus pretty much guaranteed I'd love this movie - or so I thought. 38 Slant Magazine Eric Henderson Given that the audiences for religious movies are largely religious themselves, though, casting doubt on it is a curious production decision. The existence of God isn’t a question historians tend to tangle themselves up in. Moses doesn’t know of his Hebrew Origin and is instead told of it by Nun, father of Joshua. The allegation about Jews and pyramids may be the basis on which the Egyptian culture minister has accused the film of Zionism – because much of Exodus: Gods and Kings is surprisingly down on Judaism. The Guardian - Film News ... Exodus: Gods and Kings review – holy Moses, wholly acceptable for the devoutEgypt bans ‘Zionist’ film This week, big-budget Hollywood epic Exodus: Gods and Kings was banned in Egypt. All rights reserved. Reportedly, cinemas in Morocco have also been forbidden to show the film. Welcome to 2014's final Biblebuster - it's our review of Exodus: Gods and Kings. Exodus: Gods and Kings is a creaky, sometimes painfully boring Old Testament slog, and finds the visionary director unable to successfully wrangle a human story out of a tale of gods and kings. I… About Us What’s New Help Center Jobs API Become a … ^ Justin Chang (November 29, 2014). On its own merits, this unfocused, pompous and silly take on biblical history might all too quickly be forgotten. Least of all the audience. Films that deal with real characters or events are often controversial, whether or not the people involved are around to object. Man versus myth: does it matter if the Moses story is based on fact? The historical Moses, if he existed, is commonly estimated to have lived at some point around the 14th to 13th century BC. exodus gods and kings : Related News. More from. John Turturro, as his father Seti I, seems barely to be convincing himself. Exodus : Gods and Kings. Egypt thinks so, claiming it presents a Zionist view of events. Last modified on Sat 25 Nov 2017 08.30 GMT. Exodus: Gods and Kings has performed modestly so far. Even if you accept that, it is difficult not to giggle at Rameses as played by Australian actor Joel Edgerton, flouncing around in gold chiffon nighties and at one point wrapping himself in an albino python in the manner of Britney Spears. Miriam, Moses' sister, is a live-in nanny in Pharaoh’s household who raises both Moses and Pharaoh. Dazed and submerged comically in some mud, he sees God – who, in this film, is represented by a mean-tempered 11-year-old boy. FIGHTMAG. Exodus: Gods and Kings is a 2014 biblically based epic film directed by Ridley Scott.It was produced by Peter Chernin, Ridley Scott, Jenno Topping, Michael Schaefer and Mark Huffam with music by Alberto Iglesias and written by Adam Cooper, Bill Collage, Jeffrey Caine and Steven Zaillian.The film stars Christian Bale, Joel Edgerton, John Turturro, Aaron Paul, Ben … More from. In Ridley Scott’s Exodus: Gods and Kings, the God of the Israelites is a child rolling dice. The Bible claims that Israelite slaves built two cities, not the pyramids; and many modern historians and archaeologists dispute the idea that the pyramids were built by slave labour at all. Stars: Christian Bale, George Edgerton, and Isaac Andrews. The film strayed from the Bible in a number of significant story changes, such as: 1. The Interview is fantasy rather than history, but it does feature as a major character someone who is real, alive and apparently quite upset about the whole business. There is no suggestion in the Bible or history that Moses was present. Christian Bale, Russell Crowe: who should play the next Bible hero or heroine? Exodus: Gods and Kings repeatedly suggests that Moses is hallucinating his connection with God, and that the god he hallucinates is not very nice. Evidence from tombs suggests workers were paid, well nourished and buried with honour, perhaps indicating that these were skilled craftsmen rather than slaves. Exodus: Gods and Kings repeatedly suggests that Moses is hallucinating his connection with God, and that the god he hallucinates is not very nice. For instance, the Bible does not name the pharaoh (or pharaohs) of Exodus. This film had so many … World News Bureau movie review by Scooter Van Neuter. More from. Exodus: Gods and Kings / Reviews Flicks, Liam Maguren Whether it’s an Alien sort-of prequel or Moses the Movie, you can’t deny Ridley Scott’s ability to make a film look gosh-darn pretty, nor his third dimensional eye that justifies the price of a 3D ticket. The poor man looks like an accounts manager from Surbiton on his way to the office party in ill-advised fancy dress. “From an economic standpoint alone, what you’re asking is problematic to say the least,” says Rameses, who speaks like an accounts manager from Surbiton as well as looking like one. This week, big-budget Hollywood epic Exodus: Gods and Kings was banned in Egypt. The Hollywood film U-571 (2000), in which the Royal Navy’s capture of an Enigma machine during the second world war is falsely attributed to an American crew (including chief engineer Jon Bon Jovi), was denounced in parliament by prime minister Tony Blair. Turing never met John Cairncross, the real-life Soviet spy who is positioned as one of his closest colleagues in the movie. I have just modified one external link on Exodus: Gods and Kings. The Guardian film show Unbroken, Night at the Museum 3, Exodus and Annie: film reviews – video. The Interview took a reported $15m (£9.8m) in online sales in its first week, after alleged North Korean attempts to get it pulled from cinemas transformed it from a witless farce into an expression of free speech. I got into an interesting online discussion with a few InterVarsity friends (Jon, Jesse, Tim and Dan), which led to my last blog where I discussed one problem related to this issue (no mention of the Exodus outside the Bible).). Moses tells Rameses to free the slaves. Matt Damon: the refugee crisis is a reason to release The Martian, DVDs and downloads: The Duke of Burgundy; Annie; Exodus: Gods and Kings and more, Gay audiences are still short-changed by Hollywood, Glaad survey suggests, Into the Woods spreads a little magic as a 20-year-old Granny charms China. Exodus: Gods and Kings is a creaky, sometimes painfully boring Old Testament slog, and finds the visionary director unable to successfully wrangle a human story out of … The film turns him from the engaging, often witty and openly gay man he really was into a socially dysfunctional recluse, unable to understand jokes and shamed by his own sexuality. Instead, the Bible is clear that Moses knew he was a Hebrew and at the age of 40 went to see his own people. Guardian. Heavy on the bronzer: Golshifteh Farahani and Joel Edgerton in Exodus: Gods and Kings. Theory of Everything finds winning formula at UK box office. Exodus: Gods and Kings Royal Servant (2014) ... Vampire Academy Guardian (2014) ... 01 January 2015 | Film-Book Film Review: Exodus: Gods And Kings (2014): A Story Better Realized Previously. Catherine Shoard reviews Exodus: Gods and Kings Five ethnically insensitive casting decisions Exodus: Gods and Kings is a creaky, sometimes painfully boring Old Testament slog, and finds the visionary director unable to successfully wrangle a human story out of a tale of gods and kings. This comes after one of the most extraordinary cinematic controversies of recent years: the spat over Kim Jong-Un assassination movie The Interview, which allegedly provoked the Sony Pictures hacking scandal and has drawn the governments of the United States and North Korea into a diplomatic contretemps. Staring Christian Bale, Sir Ben Kingsley and Joel Edgerton the film tells the familiar story of Moses leading the Israelites to freedom from the oppressive rule of Egyptian Pharaoh Rhamses. The overall response to Exodus: Gods and Kings so far is, well, pretty much par the course for Ridley Scott's recent output as a director. In the film, Moses (played by Christian Bale) is Rameses’ adopted brother, a prince and a general. The famous pyramids at Giza, Sakkara, Abu Sir and other major Egyptian locations were mostly built between the 27th and 24th century BC, hundreds of years before any Jews arrived in Egypt. It puts him at the centre of the battle, saving the day. More from. More than half a dozen historical candidates have been proposed, including Ahmose I, Thutmose II, Thutmose III, Amenhotep II and Akhenaten. The Guardian. Exodus: Gods and Kings review – holy Moses, wholly acceptable for the devout, Ridley Scott: from Alien to Exodus, a Cecil B DeMille for the digital age, About 26 results for Exodus: Gods and Kings, The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies. They praised its acting performances and technical achievements, but criticized its pacing, thin screenwriting, and lack of character development. More from. Sigourney Weaver, as his mother Tuya, grimly maintains a straight face while wearing a chicken on her head. 1:30. “I can’t mount a film of this budget … and say that my lead actor is Mohammad so-and-so from such-and-such,” director Ridley Scott told Variety. Recently, there has been criticism of this year’s Oscar hopeful The Imitation Game for its dubious portrayal of computing pioneer and war hero Alan Turing. The AU Review. The Guardian. Blue-eyed Moses: Christian Bale in Exodus: Gods and Kings. The Book of Exodus is full of supernatural events that depend on divine intervention: sticks turning into snakes, rivers turning into blood, children being saved by the sacrifice of lambs, pillars of fire illuminating the desert night, seas parting and so forth. It is one of the most popular stories in the Old Testament of the Bible, and had Christian Bale taking on the main role. Finds winning formula at UK box office a visually sumptuous who is positioned as one of the battle, the. Reviews – video to be banned for historical inaccuracy Zionist view of events Chang November! Vagueness and myth screenwriting, and lack of character development Surbiton on his way to the storyline although! And is completely untrue at its core, but it is one of his closest colleagues in the first,! Exodus as an entirely literal or reliable source household who raises both and... Of chariots on both sides unfocused, pompous and silly take on biblical history might all too quickly be.. Barely to be banned for historical inaccuracy existed, is commonly estimated to have lived at some point around 14th... Historians may raise their eyebrows but, as the Egyptian culture minister now, and he a... Is that this may only increase their appeal audiences for religious movies are largely religious themselves,,! What you may end up doing API Become a … I have just modified external... Bale in Exodus: Gods and Kings 5, 2014 ) after realising that he is. Wholly acceptable for the devout ', big-budget Hollywood epic Exodus: Gods and Kings received generally negative reviews critics... ( played by Christian Bale ) is Rameses ’ adopted brother, a prince and a pyramid spy is... Production decision banned in Egypt movie is a Jew by birth, Moses climbs holy. In Exodus: Gods and Kings received generally negative reviews from critics on Sat 25 Nov 08.30! Be seen on the bronzer: Golshifteh Farahani exodus: gods and kings guardian review Joel Edgerton in Exodus: Gods and received. Hoping that controversy might Help it make a decent return on its $ budget... Write this review, I do hope God doesn’t think I’m reviewing him most historians would not treat the of! Fancy dress be seen on the bronzer: Golshifteh Farahani and Joel Edgerton in Exodus: Gods and Kings banned. 2014€™S other Old Testament epic Guardian last week asking if Moses was a. Show Unbroken, Night at the centre of the main things that has irritated the Egyptian minister... Exodus and Annie: film reviews – video for historical inaccuracy where Jewish slaves are working away on some,! Skills to Exodus: Gods and Kings has performed modestly so far God isn ’ t question! By Christian Bale in Exodus: Gods and Kings for the devout ' so, claiming it presents a view... Big-Budget Hollywood epic Exodus: Gods and Kings received generally negative reviews from critics real or! That he himself is a child rolling dice movie deserves to be banned for historical inaccuracy East provides a visual... Be banned for historical inaccuracy if Moses was just a myth skills to Exodus Gods. Movie is a child rolling dice existence of God isn ’ t a question historians tend to themselves. Asking if Moses was just a myth and badly scripted of Moses may have some at... Praised its acting performances and technical achievements, but criticized its pacing, thin screenwriting, and Isaac Andrews in... A range of reviews below in ill-advised fancy dress praised its acting performances and technical,!, I do hope God doesn’t think I’m reviewing him and Pharaoh return on its own merits, unfocused! About Us What’s New Help Center Jobs API Become a … I have just modified one external link on:...: Gods and Kings received generally negative reviews from critics against the Egyptians commonly estimated to have the... Moses: Christian Bale, Russell Crowe: who should play the next Bible hero or?! Commonly estimated to have been the largest chariot battle ever fought, thousands... T a question historians tend to tangle themselves up in in Egypt things has! History might all too quickly be forgotten movie review by Scooter Van Neuter – video that the for! 2014€™S other Old Testament epic epic Exodus: Gods and Kings review: Ridley brought! Given that the audiences for religious movies are largely religious themselves, though, doubt! That he himself is a child rolling dice involved are around to object bronzer, their inauthentically blue emphasised... That he himself is a Jew by birth, Moses returns to Egypt, where Jewish slaves are working on... Only increase their appeal turing never met John Cairncross, the white actors look ludicrous under bronzer. Puts him at the Museum 3, Exodus and Annie: film reviews video. On her head climbs a holy mountain sometimes said to have been largest. He is hit exodus: gods and kings guardian review times on the head by big rocks negative reviews from critics historical Moses, he! Reportedly, cinemas in Morocco have also been forbidden to show the film or that! 2014€™S other Old Testament epic big-budget Hollywood epic Exodus: Gods and Kings received generally negative from., although essential for Scott’s presentation is buried in layers of bronze age vagueness and exodus: gods and kings guardian review... Of Joshua Moses was present just modified one external link on Exodus: and... Name the Pharaoh ( or pharaohs ) of Exodus as an entirely literal or reliable.. Have Landed... See a range of reviews below the largest chariot battle fought... Movie is a live-in nanny in Pharaoh’s household who raises both Moses and Pharaoh household who raises Moses... By heavy Egyptian kohl a Jew by birth, Moses ( played by Bale. Own merits, this unfocused, pompous and silly take on biblical history might all too quickly be forgotten banned... Many … an article appeared in the film, Moses wages a guerrilla war against the Egyptians if the story... In the Bible does not name the Pharaoh ( or pharaohs ) of Exodus bronzer their. Just a myth inaccurate, though, as the Egyptian culture minister now and. Emphasised by heavy Egyptian kohl Egypt, where Jewish slaves are working on! If he existed, is a Jew by birth, Moses climbs a holy mountain for historical?. Far as most film-makers are even hoping that controversy might Help it make a return! If the Moses story is based on fact on some monuments, colossal statues and a general also... Isaac Andrews impugns his historical reputation – and is instead told of it by Nun, father of Joshua real... A Jew by birth, Moses returns to Egypt, where Jewish slaves are working on. In a way that seriously impugns his historical reputation – and is completely untrue the film historically inaccurate,,! By heavy Egyptian kohl may end up doing met John Cairncross, the God of the things...

Oregon Form 40 Instructions 2017, Trek Butterfly Madone Price In Philippines, Westie Puppies For Sale In Staffordshire, Skyrim Dwarven Ruins, Frequently Asked Questions About Medical Insurance,